All your favorite posts, one swipe away
ABBACCHIO MY SWEETHEART UFH I LOVE HIM SO MUCH☹️☹️☹️☹️
I see requests are open 🙏 and first of all, omfg I absolutely loved your response to my nonchalant reader confessing to Bucci gang+Trish 😭❤️ tho it left me wondering what if 👀👀 nonchalant reader is not taken seriously, so they double down with their confession by doing the exact opposite of sth casual because now they do something more elaborated, extravagant or/and even obnoxious (like fancy dinner, a big boquet of flowers, heartshaped chocolates or maybe even balloons) to make their point clear and sure to get across this time. Like !!! I meant it, I am in love with you!! but this time doing the grand gestures gets Nonchalant Reader flustered when repeating outloud that they love them
Masterlist here <3
I love this so much!!! I seriously had so much fun writing this and I hope you enjoy <3
Og post of the confession here <3
Bruno Bucciarati
The first confession over breakfast had left Bruno intrigued, but you could tell he thought you were joking. So now, you’re sitting across from him at a ridiculously fancy restaurant with chandeliers, classical music, and a waiter in a tux pouring sparkling water into crystal glasses
Bruno, ever composed, places his napkin neatly in his lap, a polite smile on his lips. “This is… unexpected,” he says smoothly. “Special occasion?”
You fidget with the edge of your menu, trying to maintain your nonchalant facade despite your flushed cheeks. “Yeah. I, uh… wanted to clarify something.”
He tilts his head, curious. “Oh?”
The words catch in your throat, but you force them out anyway. “I meant what I said. I’m… I’m in love with you.”
Bruno leans forward slightly, eyes softening, but your nerves hit like a freight train. “Like, actually,” you blurt, voice a bit too loud. “Not some breakfast joke. I got a whole table reservation and—”
The waiter appears, placing an elaborate bouquet of roses between you. You stare at it in mortification
Bruno hides a smile behind his hand. “I’m beginning to see that.”
“I panicked!” you hiss
Bruno’s laugh is warm, genuine. “You’re charming when you panic, did you know that?”
Narancia Ghirga
The first confession during video games had left Narancia completely flustered, but clearly, he thought you were messing with him. Time to up the ante
So now, you’re standing outside his window with a boombox blaring cheesy love songs, dressed way too nicely for no reason
Narancia sticks his head out the window, eyes wide. “WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?!”
“I LOVE YOU!” you yell over the music, face burning but fully committed. “LIKE, FOR REAL!”
The neighbors are already peeking through their windows, and you’re regretting every second of this decision
Narancia bursts out laughing, leaning on the windowsill. “Wait, you’re serious?! Oh my god, you’re insane!”
“I KNOW!” you yell back, hands shaking as you fumble with the boombox to turn it off. “But I meant it!”
He grins so wide it makes your embarrassment almost worth it. “You didn’t have to do all this, dummy. I already like you too.”
You freeze. “…Oh?”
“Yeah! But this was awesome.”
Guido Mista
The kitchen confession had gone over way too casually. So now, you’ve decided to go full drama mode—heart-shaped chocolates, flowers, and a cheesy handwritten card are all set on the table
Mista walks in, blinks at the sight, then bursts out laughing. “What’s all this? Valentine’s Day come early?”
You groan, already regretting this. “I’m trying to be serious here, Mista.”
He grins, picking up the card. “Aw, you even wrote me a love letter?” He reads it aloud with way too much enthusiasm
You slap a hand over your face, cheeks burning. “Okay, okay, stop.”
Mista cackles, setting the card down. “You’re so flustered, it’s kinda cute.”
You glare at him. “I’m in love with you, idiot.”
His teasing expression falters for just a second before softening. “Yeah, I know,” he says, smiling warmly now. “I just wanted to see you get all worked up first.”
Fugo Pannacotta
Fugo’s intense logical nature means your first confession barely registered. So now, you’re standing in front of him holding a massive bouquet of flowers, wearing an outfit that makes you feel like an awkward rom-com protagonist
He blinks at you, visibly confused. “What is this?”
“I’m clarifying my previous statement,” you say stiffly, shoving the bouquet toward him
He cautiously takes it, looking between you and the flowers like you’ve just handed him a bomb. “Why?”
“Because,” you mutter, shifting on your feet, “you didn’t believe me. I meant it, Fugo. I’m in love with you.”
Your face feels like it’s on fire as you force the words out. Fugo’s expression shifts from confusion to realization, and his ears turn bright red
“You didn’t need to do all this,” he mutters, looking away
“Well, you weren’t getting it,” you snap, embarrassed
He glances back at you, a rare, shy smile tugging at his lips. “I get it now.”
Giorno Giovanna
The garden confession had been brushed off too smoothly, so now you’ve set up a full candlelit dinner. Roses, soft music, and a carefully plated meal—the works
Giorno enters, visibly surprised but composed as ever. “This is… elaborate.”
“Yeah, well,” you mumble, pulling out a chair for him. “Needed to make a point.”
He sits gracefully, watching you with amusement. “And that point is?”
You sit across from him, heart racing. “I love you,” you say, voice cracking slightly. “Like, really love you. Not just some random garden comment.”
His eyes soften, and a small smile graces his lips. “You’ve certainly made your feelings clear.”
“Good,” you mutter, poking at your food
He reaches across the table, taking your hand gently. “Thank you,” he says quietly. “I was never confused—just waiting for you to realize how much this means to you.”
Leone Abbacchio
After your nonchalant confession was brushed off, you decided to go all out. Now, you’re standing awkwardly in front of Abbacchio with a gift bag and a bottle of expensive wine
He raises an eyebrow. “What’s this supposed to be?”
“A… grand gesture,” you say, voice cracking slightly
He crosses his arms, unimpressed. “You feeling okay?”
“No,” you grumble. “This is stupid. I don’t know why I—whatever, here.” You shove the gift bag toward him
He takes it reluctantly, pulling out a small, heart-shaped card. The corner of his mouth twitches. “Seriously?”
“I love you,” you blurt out, feeling like you might actually combust. “Happy now?”
He stares at you for a long moment before letting out a low chuckle. “You really went all out, huh?”
“I panicked,” you admit miserably
“Well,” he says, smirking, “I guess I’m flattered.”
Trish Una
After your casual confession, Trish had brushed it off with disbelief. So now, you’re standing outside her dressing room with balloons, chocolates, and a handwritten love letter
She opens the door, takes one look at you, and blinks. “What is this?”
“I’m making a point,” you mutter, cheeks burning. “I meant it. I’m in love with you.”
Trish raises an eyebrow, clearly amused. “You’re blushing.”
“I know,” you groan. “This is embarrassing, okay?”
She crosses her arms, leaning against the doorframe. “So you really love me, huh?”
“Yes!” you snap. “God, don’t make me say it again.”
Trish laughs, stepping closer. “I have to admit, I didn’t expect this. But I guess it’s kind of cute.”
“Great. Glad you’re entertained.”
She grins. “I’ll take the chocolates, though. And maybe we can talk about this over dinner—my treat.”
If you’d like any tweaks let me know! I hope you enjoyed this cz I found it so cute <3
If you enjoyed this make sure to check out my other posts, and if you’d like anything specific written for a jjba character/squad you can request it if my requests are open!